Thoughts On The Toilet Tissue Issue
Recently at Christmas I overheard three of my nephews griping about the toilet paper in their college dorms. Their chief complaint was their school’s cheap tissue is too chafing.
(This is not a subject you would normally bring up at Christmas or in mixed company, but they are, after all, boys in college. And to their credit, the females were on the other side of the room. Also, I was impressed that they knew what “chafing” meant. Obviously, these are college dollars well spent.)
Another gripe was the toilet paper is too flimsy, so they have to use way more of it than the good stuff, which they are certain is costing their university a lot more than would buying better bunwad. (My word, not theirs. I never wrote the word “bunwad” before and I just wanted to see how it felt.)
Anyway, this got me reflecting on the classic conundrum of HOW toilet paper should be mounted on the wall, and the gratifying way that problem was solved for me. This may be something you too have struggled with, and have always wondered about. Not that it’s kept you up at night or anything, but somehow nobody ever mentioned it or you were absent that day in school or whatever. If so, your days of confusion are over.
On the other hand, maybe your mother taught you to mount the toilet paper one way, and one way only, and so for you that was final. My own personal mother, as it happens, is quite hygenic – almost anally so (is that an oxymoron?) – but for some reason she never once mentioned this fundamental piece of housekeeping. Which now that I think about it is astonishing. She certainly let us know the exact right perfect way to do everything else. I feel it was an oversight in our upbringing. (Note to self: Ask Mom why she omitted specific instructions about the tissue issue.)
But back to the basic problem, which is this: do you mount the roll so that it dispenses from the rear, dropping down next to the wall, or do you mount it so the paper comes over the top and unrolls away from the wall?
Before I give you the correct answer and the expert who clarified this for everybody, everywhere and forever, I want you to think about it for a minute. One might argue that the first option is better because the paper unrolls close to the wall and is thus slightly neater and tidier, but possibly a little harder to reach, harder to touch only the paper you want, and harder to tear cleanly. And we all know how frustrating it is to tear the tissue in the middle of a sheet.
Whereas with the second option (outward and over the top, which could apply to this whole blog post) it’s a bit easier to reach, but with a greater chance of spinning the roll out of control, unleashing several yards of toilet paper cascading over the bathroom floor, leaving you with the difficult decision of whether to re-roll it back onto the spool (even though it’s impossible to ever make that look right) or to just gather it all up and throw it away. Which seems wasteful.
It’s a tough choice, I know, but what do you think?
For the one or two of you still reading at this point, here is the correct answer:
The toilet paper should be mounted so that the paper comes over the top and away from the wall.
“Ha!” you say. How can I be so cocksure this is the proper mode of installation?
Because a long time ago on The Tonight show I heard Jerry Lewis expound at length on this very subject while he was guest-hosting for Johnny Carson. I can’t exactly recall his precise arguments right this very minute, but I can assure you he was adamant. He was dead certain the toilet paper should come over the top, away from the wall. And I figure if anybody knows about toilet paper – if anybody should have the final word on toilet paper – it would be Jerry Lewis. So for me, case closed.
As an example of how this can play out, years ago I lived with my brother and his wife for a few months and we shared a bathroom. They always had the toilet paper mounted the wrong way, so whenever I answered the call of nature, I switched it around to the right way. Incredibly, neither of them ever mentioned this. They never brought it up or asked me why I turned the toilet paper around. Instead, they quietly switched it back. I always thought that was weird.
I always hoped one of them would say something. I thought it would be fun to let them know that Jerry Lewis had made the definitive statement on this. (Plus, you would naturally want to be prepared in case Jerry ever dropped by for a visit or an inspection.) But sadly, I never got that opportunity. Maybe now one of them will read this blog post and we can finally bring that dark episode of family history out of the closet.
(By the way, I would never switch the toilet paper at anybody’s house except a family member. That would just be rude.)
One final thing. I once participated in a humor workshop where the leader told us to divide ourselves into two groups: crumplers and folders. We all looked at each other blankly, with no idea what he meant, until he yelled, “People, I’m talking toilet paper!”
It was more than we wanted to know about each other, but funny.
© 2012 Greg Tamblyn



